Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kent Clizbe's avatar

Linh,

Please don't take this as criticism. It's a sincere question that comes up each time you publish something about American underclass culture.

Your subject matter is interesting. Wondering why you chose/choose to focus, in America, on the scummy lowlife dive bars and the down-on-their-luck unfortunates, criminals and soon-to-be-criminals who inhabit them?

Specifically, why that focus in America, while in Vietnam you seem to focus on more wholesome and family-friendly locations and people?

There are plenty of scumbags in Vietnam. Plenty of lowlifes and dive bars. Tattooed gangsters and their hoes, drug-runners, thieves, drunks and druggies, wife-beaters, women beating their husband's mistresses, and much, much more. Why not interact, hang out, and write about them? Your skills at inter-cultural translation could provide interesting portraits of the same class in Vietnam that you so ardently pursue(d) in America.

Thanks.

Expand full comment
Tom's avatar

From a literary perspective, the underclass can be more interesting than the middle class or the rich (see Orwell and Twain, who hang out with bums and vagrants and wrote interestingly about that). The middle class is usually more boring or depressing as a subject, although of course there are exceptions. Even Borges, an artistic writer if there ever was one, who hang out with upper-class people and the literati, but his preferred stories among the ones he wrote were about gaucho thugs fighting with knives in taverns (or vikings fighting with swords, which is more or less the same thing). The rich... Well, Fitzgerald wrote about it but his famous novel seems a bit fake to me. Proust is interesting in his childhood recollections but as he drags on and on later about princesses and dukes in their salons, it becomes a bit boring. Perhaps it would have been more interesting if he went to some Parisian low-class bar of the time to see "how the other half lives".

Expand full comment
47 more comments...

No posts